1. Prologue
2. What If?
3. It’s a Sign
4. A Map of New York
5. You Never Know
6. Ain’t No Man Manhattan
7. What the F**k?
8. Here I Go
9. You Don’t Need to Love Me
10. No More Wasted Time
11. Surprise
12. This Day/Walking by a Wedding
13. Hey Kid
14. Some Other Me
15. Best Worst Mistake
16. I Hate You
17. A Map of New York (Reprise)
18. You Learn to Live Without
19. The Moment Explodes
20. Love While You Can
21. What Would You Do?
22. Always Starting Over
23. What If? (Reprise)